Not affiliated with FMCSA or USDOT

Audit Readiness Kit · 16 automatic-failure rules · Documents · How the audit works

The 16 violations that automatically fail a new entrant safety audit

FMCSA lists 16 violations in 49 CFR 385.321(b). If the auditor finds even one of them, the audit is failed, whatever the rest of your files look like.

#Rule (49 CFR)Violation and what it means
1382.115(a) / 382.105No alcohol or drug testing program
You must have a DOT testing program in place from the day you start operating, usually through a consortium or third-party administrator.
2382.305No random testing program
Every CDL driver, including an owner who drives, must be in a random drug and alcohol testing pool.
3382.201Using a driver with an alcohol concentration of 0.04 or higher
A driver with a 0.04 result cannot do safety-sensitive work until the return-to-duty process is complete.
4382.211Using a driver who refused a required test
A refusal is treated like a positive: the driver comes off safety-sensitive work.
5382.215Using a driver known to have tested positive
A driver with a verified positive drug test cannot drive until return-to-duty is complete.
6383.3(a) / 383.23(a)Using a driver without a valid CDL
Anyone operating a CDL-class vehicle needs a valid CDL of the right class.
7383.37(b)Using a driver whose CDL or CLP is disqualified
You may not use a driver whose license is suspended, revoked or cancelled, or who has lost the right to operate a CMV in a State.
8383.51(a)Letting a disqualified driver drive
A driver disqualified under the CDL rules stays off the road for the whole disqualification period.
9387.7(a)Operating without the required minimum insurance
The required liability coverage must be in force for every day you operate.
10387.31(a)Passenger carrier without the required coverage
Applies to passenger carriers only.
11391.15(a)Using a disqualified driver
Covers disqualification under Part 391, for example after loss of license or certain offenses.
12391.11(b)(4)Using a physically unqualified driver
Each driver needs a current medical examiner's certificate from an examiner on the National Registry.
13395.8(a)No record of duty status
Counts as an automatic failure when records are missing for 51% or more of those the auditor checks.
14396.9(c)(2)Driving a vehicle placed out of service before repairs
A vehicle put out of service at a roadside inspection cannot move until it is repaired.
15396.11(a)(3)Not repairing out-of-service defects from a driver inspection report
Out-of-service defects a driver reports on a DVIR must be fixed before the vehicle is driven again.
16396.17(a)No periodic (annual) inspection
Counts as an automatic failure when the inspection is missing on 51% or more of the vehicles checked.

Two of the 16 work on a 51% threshold

Missing records of duty status (395.8(a)) and missing periodic inspections (396.17(a)) are automatic failures only when they affect 51% or more of the records or vehicles the auditor examines. Below that level they are still violations and still count against you, but they do not fail the audit on their own.

Which ones catch small carriers most often

  • Drug and alcohol program. An owner-operator with a CDL needs a testing program and a random pool even with no employees. Joining a consortium after the audit notice arrives does not fix the months before it.
  • Pre-employment steps done late. A negative pre-employment test and a full Clearinghouse query must be in hand before a driver's first day. These are not on the list of 16, but they are among the first things an auditor checks.
  • Annual inspections. With two or three vehicles, one overdue trailer can put you at or over 51%.
  • Insurance gaps. A lapse of a few days between policies still counts.

What happens if you fail

FMCSA sends a written notice. You then have 60 days to submit evidence of corrective action (45 days for carriers of passengers or placarded hazardous materials). If the response is not accepted in time, your registration is revoked and you are placed out of service. How the audit works covers the timeline.

Source: 49 CFR Part 385, Subpart D (eCFR), sections 385.319 and 385.321.

Want this applied to your own drivers and trucks?The Audit Readiness Kit is an Excel workbook that scores your files against these rules, lists your gaps in order of risk and builds a 12-month deadline calendar. One-time purchase, 14-day refund.Get the kit — $99

Rules checked 17 November 2026 against 49 CFR and FMCSA publications. Rules change; the regulation is the authority. This page is educational and is not legal advice.